One of the current joys of my life is school-subsidized busing (bussing?). Actually, the route I live on now—after moving*—is free to everyone, so there are lots of interesting people to watch.

There are also lots of ads to read inside the bus—apartments for rent, “don’t do drugs” campaigns, etc. And, occasionally, church advertising. This time, there was an ad for a local UMC’s (I’m assuming) college/young adult service. The ad has a sort of smooth, contemporary look, with lots of blues and blacks, and text in different shades and styles that reads, “Contemporary Worship,” “Multimedia,” “Casual Dress,” “Practical Sermons,” “Modern Music,” “Free Lunch for College Students.”

So, basically, a laundry list of what young people are supposed to want from church. (If you haven’t seen Rev. yet, watch this clip from the BBC. Seriously. In three minutes, it embodies everything I’m talking about here. And it’s amazing.)

The thing is, I don’t really think church is about what we can get out of the worship service. I say this as someone who chose her church based heavily on the manner of worship—falling in love with liturgical worship is one of the things that brought be to TEC, and my parish was the one with a choir—and organ. I’m more of an Adam girl than a Darren girl (watch the clip and you’ll see). So maybe I can’t talk.

I’m pretty sure, though, that church is about worship, and about learning to better love God and our neighbor—which isn’t something we learn through “practical sermons.” I think it’s something we learn through the act of worship, through the Eucharist, through the beauty of the service, and through our relationships with the people (and objects) of the church. Not that a good homily can’t be part of this; my Reformed roots have instilled in me an appreciation for good preaching. But I don’t go to church for a good performance and a few sound bites of Bible-as-handbook style sermons. I want so much more than that.

This summer I went to a summer-ministry church service that I’d enjoyed as a child, and now find almost uncomfortably irreverent. Not that the leaders and congregation have any ill intent or even that they’re not there Sunday mornings for the glory of God—they are. But somewhere, something got lost.

It’s not formality I crave. I had Eucharist with a handful of people in a mostly-deserted sports bar late on a Monday night, and it was among the coolest General-Convention experiences I had—and it was utterly reverent, even surrounded by the jokes and laughter of a slightly kooky group of young adults.

I think what I’m looking for is something like beauty, which is a slippery fish—eye of the beholder and all that. And contemporary services and be beautiful, don’t get me wrong, but there seems to be something in the nature of trying to be “relevant” that shuffles over beautiful things. Then again, maybe I’m a relic of antiquary trapped in a 20-something’s body with my outmoded ideas of what is beautiful—I don’t know. What I do know is that on my bus ride, God’s grandeur shines through for me far, far clearer in the posters of poems written by local students than in the posters advertising a shiny, new church service.


What are your thoughts? Why do you go to church (or not)? Am I just biased against/harping on contemporary churches? Preaching to the choir? Do you wish for a more practical payout from Sunday mornings? Do you wish for a smoothie machine at coffee hour?


*Duh. Should’ve been on my list of summer stuff. I guess I blocked it out. I moved to a new apartment, with four other people, who are pretty cool. It was totally worth the trauma of the actual moving part—even all the bruises.


3 thoughts on “Wired!

  1. I grew up in a liturgical church, and so to me a contemporary service just means guitars, songs from 1980 instead of 1480, and different words to the liturgy at the beginning of the service. Sometimes we throw in the modern translation of the Lord’s Prayer–and get to hear all the old people complain about it.

    So, while I saw that episode of Rev and recognize in it the worship styles of a lot of my friends, I can’t really relate. I’ve been to maybe two of that kind of contemporary service and, honestly, it was pretty much like I hadn’t been to church at all. It’s a concert and a lecture, not a worship service.

    Too often I see the other extreme–bitter complaining if we say “is” instead of “art” in the Lord’s Prayer, stone-faced silence in response to a song played on guitar instead of organ (even if it’s the same hymn that we sing on other Sunday’s with the organ), a total resistance to doing anything any way other than the way it’s always been done.

    And while I would never be tempted by the billboard on that bus, and I honestly prefer most hymns to most worship songs, I do really appreciate the variety within my chosen form (that is, variety still within the overall liturgical tradition). So I can see how things that I find completely crazy (like speaking in tongues, for a non-“young adult contemporary wired!” example) could to others be beautiful, and worshipful, and how they could find a formal liturgy stifling or unappealing.

    All of this to say, I’m with you, an antiquarian who prefers thoughtful Biblical exegesis to soundbite sermons–but I can understand that not everyone feels that way, and that’s okay, too.

    That all circles around what perhaps was your real point, that adults trying to lure in teenagers/young adults by being hip is annoying, fake, and typically unsuccessful in organizations of all stripes and is particularly unsuited to the church, because it makes a mockery of reverence. And to that, as a fellow young adult, I say, Amen.

    • Thanks for this thoughtful reply, Katie! I agree on all points. I think you’ve hit on an important issue: older adults deciding what (*all*) younger adults want is not the way to bring young adults into church. And then there’s the shocking reality that not all young adults like the same things. (What?!) Probably all of us, younger and older alike, could benefit from a little variety and a healthy dose of adaptability. 🙂

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s